OREO Mint Creme vs. Thins Mint Creme: Which Mint Cookie Is Right for You?

Quick Answer

Choose OREO Mint Creme if you want the classic thick cookie with a bold mint filling and a satisfying crunch. Choose OREO Thins Mint Creme if you prefer a lighter, crispier cookie that's great for snacking or baking. Both deliver the same minty flavor, but the texture and portion size make them suited for different moments.

Mint and chocolate is a classic pairing, and OREO has two tempting options: the original OREO Mint Creme and the slimmer OREO Thins Mint Creme. Both are mint cookies, but they're not interchangeable in every situation. The differences go beyond looks—texture, crunch, and how they behave in recipes all matter.

In this comparison, we'll break down what each cookie offers so you can decide which one belongs in your pantry. Whether you're planning a baking project, packing snacks, or just craving something sweet, we'll help you pick the right mint Oreo.

Texture and Crunch: Classic vs. Thin

The most obvious difference is thickness. The classic OREO Mint Creme features the familiar plump cookie with a generous layer of mint creme. It delivers that iconic 'twist, lick, dunk' experience with a sturdy bite. The cookie is thicker, so it holds up well to a quick dunk in milk without falling apart.

OREO Thins Mint Creme, on the other hand, is noticeably slimmer. The wafer is crisp and delicate, offering a lighter crunch that some find more satisfying for snacking straight from the package. Because it's thin, it's less filling per cookie, which can be a plus if you want a small treat without committing to a full-size Oreo.

• Classic Mint Creme: thick, sturdy, ideal for dunking.
• Thins Mint Creme: thin, crispy, perfect for a light snack.

Portion Size and Snacking

When it comes to snacking, portion control is often the deciding factor. The classic OREO Mint Creme comes in a family-size pack, which is great for sharing but might tempt you to eat more than one. Each cookie is more substantial, so two or three can feel like a satisfying serving.

OREO Thins Mint Creme also comes in a family-size pack, but because the cookies are thinner, you might find yourself reaching for more to feel satisfied. However, if you're counting calories or want a lighter option, the thins allow you to enjoy the minty flavor with fewer calories per cookie. Think about your snacking habits: do you prefer one hearty cookie or several lighter ones?

Baking with Mint Oreos

Baking is where these two cookies really diverge. The classic OREO Mint Creme is a reliable choice for recipes that call for crushed cookies, like cheesecake crusts or no-bake desserts. Its thicker wafer holds up well when crushed and mixed with butter, creating a sturdy base.

OREO Thins Mint Creme can also be used in baking, but it behaves differently. Because the cookies are thinner, they crush into finer crumbs that may absorb moisture differently. They work well as a decorative topping or a delicate crust, but you may need to adjust your recipe. If you're making a crust that needs structure, the classic is safer; if you want a lighter crumb, thins could be a fun twist.

Value and Packaging

Price is always a consideration. Both the classic OREO Mint Creme and OREO Thins Mint Creme are available at a similar price point in family-size packs. However, the classic pack contains more ounces, which might offer better value per ounce if you're feeding a crowd.

That said, if you're trying to manage portions or prefer the thinner texture, the value equation changes. The thins might be worth the slightly higher cost per ounce because they help you avoid overindulging. Check the unit price on the shelf to see which fits your budget and eating style.

The Tradeoff: Classic vs. Thins

• Classic OREO Mint Creme: Thicker cookie, bolder crunch, and a generous mint filling. Best for dunking and recipes that need structure. Choose this if you want a hearty, satisfying cookie experience.
• OREO Thins Mint Creme: Slimmer, crispier, and lighter. Great for snacking and adding a delicate crunch to desserts. Choose this if you prefer a lighter bite or want to manage portions.
• Baking Use: Classic works better for crusts and bases; Thins are better for toppings and finer crumbs. Match the cookie to your recipe's texture needs.

Product Facts

• OREO Mint Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, Family Size, 18.71 oz(18.71 OZ (Pack of 2)): Our loyalty program members get exclusive access to flash sales and early bird offers on Oreo products. If you're a frequent Oreo buyer, joining the loyalty program can help you save on your favorite mint cookies, making the classic family-size pack even more affordable.
• OREO Thins Mint Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, Family Size, 11.78 oz(11.78 Ounce (Pack of 1)): Looking for a deal? Check out our outlet section for discounted Oreo products. If you're on the fence about which mint Oreo to try, the outlet section might have a discounted Thins pack, letting you test the thinner option without a big commitment.

Which Mint Oreo Fits You?

Best for

• Classic OREO Mint Creme: Dunkers, bakers making sturdy crusts, and anyone who loves the traditional Oreo feel.
• OREO Thins Mint Creme: Snackers who want a lighter cookie, and bakers looking for delicate crumb toppings.

Not for

• Classic OREO Mint Creme: Not ideal if you're strictly counting calories per cookie or prefer a delicate crunch.
• OREO Thins Mint Creme: Not the best choice for recipes that need a thick, sturdy cookie base.

Both OREO Mint Creme and OREO Thins Mint Creme deliver that beloved mint-chocolate combo, but they serve different purposes. If you want a classic, satisfying cookie that holds up to milk and baking, go with the original. If you prefer a lighter, crispier snack that's easier to portion, the Thins are a great pick. Consider your snacking and baking habits, and you'll know which one deserves a spot in your cart.